Community Blogs


House Fire--A simulated claim for discussion

Source: Forum Post Started by Racko on 9/19/2006

  • 17 April 2010
  • Author: CADO Admin
  • Number of views: 7928
House Fire--A simulated claim for discussion

To kill some time in this lull period & spread some knowledge, here is the scenario (or scenarios) as you see fit to make it. I will lay out the limited info as follows, and let's see where it goes.

Heavy fire loss occurs in a single family dwelling. Cov is HO-3, no issues with eff dates. Insureds have just left home about 6:00 p.m., a couple hours before fire breaks out and is discovered. High winds fan the flames and each house on either side sustain heat/smoke damage before the fire is brought under control. Let's say both neighboring houses now have some melted vinyl siding, one sided 2 years ago and the other 12 years ago. The elderly neighbor next door initially beat on the insured's door trying to see if they were OK, and burned his hand. He then rushed home to get his wheelchair bound wife out of their house, but she spends a week in the hospital with smoke inhalation related complications.

The insureds are a young couple, both smokers, with a 6 year old son. They just moved in about 2 years ago, only work in the house since they came was replacing the kitchen flooring, and adding a center island with a new cooktop on it. These were professionally installed within the past 6 months.

You receive the claim assignment. The only loss info given is: Dwelling fire, appears to be total loss, possibly started in or near kitchen or in basement below kitchen. Neighbors have damage/injury.

When you 1st arrive at the loss, you are also "greeted" by Mr. Red Handed neighbor and his son-in-law who happens to be a well known plaintiff's attorney. You now discover that the neighbor is insured by the same carrier you are working for, but they haven't reported this loss to their agent yet because they've been waiting for you.

Now, where did you start, what is your plan of action, what do you find out, and how does this claim end? The stories will change as you will each come up with different findings in your investigation.

Old timers please hold your horses, and save critiques til later...thanx! Newbies & not-so newbies, jump in.

Note: The above is from a CADO forum that is no longer online but the 52 replies to the above post are (will be) posted below.  We do know the member ID but not the user connected to the Member ID.

Comment 1- First Posted on 9/20/2006 9:24:00 AM by Angus99

Great scenario!!

Briefly, a little respect empathy/sympathy to neighbor but suggest that he file a claim for property damages to his agent first. I may suggest to the neighbor to call his agent while i was at the property where there loss originated. I would call my claims manager and suggest that since i was near the property that i was able to adjust all properties at once. You need to document the damages to the adjoining properties anyway. Lastly, in regards to the neighbor, it will be presumed that the neighbors attorney will present you with a liability claim. I'll mention that later.

 Adjust claim for the insured whom reported the loss. Attempt to establish a C&O. Expect to hire a C&O expert. Document, scope, photos, estimates, etc....etc....

 Liability-(i worked for 2 carriers in over 5 years and had many subro cases in which the insured and claimant were both insured by the same happens)

 Two possibilities determined by the cause of loss. 1)If the cause of loss is determined as accidental, there is no negligence from the homeowner. Ain't paying for the damages to either adjoining properties nor for the neighbors injuries. Insured haven't breached any duties.2)that the loss was intentional-possibly it can be denied but better get the carriers attorneys prepared.

 I hope this briefly sums up my position. Great educational tool here racko!! I have handled many similar claims and they can be fun to adjust.

 Ohhhh....anybody want to give some claims(daily) to a starving Cat/Multi-Line adjuster in Virginia? Lol, this is getting bad, eating oatmeal for lunch and dinner every day and night is getting old (LOL)


Comment 2 - First Posted on 9/20/2006 10:32:00 AM by Clayton

 It is a fine scenario, a very typical type of dwelling fire loss; that is, packed full of unknowns with many stones to be turned and explored and many dusty trails to lead you in different directions during the adjustment. 

 My horses have long since gone to pasture, and this is not a critique, but, how is a "newbie" - as characterized in CADO - supposed to write about the adventures of adjusting this scenario? 

 A basic principal as you progress in any career, and claims is a good of an example as any, is that you do not accept assignments that you are not trained and experienced to handle. 

 With the scenario presented, what your Claims Manager - for the one assigned claim you have - does not want to hear, is you calling him/her to ask for the two other claims.  You have absolutely no idea, at that time in the scenario that it is suggested you go looking for more related claims; as to what the cause is, nor have you done any investigation to consider and determine negligence either by the insured or a third party. 

Comment 3 - First Posted on 9/20/2006 10:39:00 AM by 10716

 Oh great experienced adjusters...please explain in FULL DISCLOSURE, NEGLIGENCE.   Many homes today are in fact DIY projects and are done quite well.  Many products are replacing older ones which are of higher quality or standard than the original. 

Thank you.

Comment 4 - First Posted on 9/20/2006 11:08:00 AM by Angus99

What i think the original poster is requesting are ideas on how to adjust this loss. Its educational and maybe it can help someone out.  If i am reading the responses to date, correctly, why criticize?


Comment 5 - First Posted on 9/20/2006 11:15:00 AM by 10716

 Never mind [:(]....I'll go first.

 I arrive at my scheduled appointment, meeting with insureds on the site loss.  First things first, customer service- addressing insureds displacement issues.  I would also inquire about neighbors and get their contact info if available from insured.  Mr. Red Handed would be advised to contact HIS insurance company if he had any issues or concerns for HIS property and politely be dismissed from insureds scope.

 I would ask insured to walk me thru the damages, taking pics to represent actual damages AND insureds story.  Now I have their undivided attention because I have SEEN the damages.  So I get into the ale issues, get the receipts of those expenses.  Review current contact info and make sure they have my contact info.  I would then tackle the scope of damages most likely without interruption.  Once I have scoped insured, I would then get my pics of both neighbors exterior damages for dated reference and documentation.  I tell the insureds that we will have ongoing communication, encourage insureds to stay in touch, keep receipts and secure property.

  I make contact for fire dept. report while going back to office to work.  Now I will input my scope inspection into estimating software.

Comment 6 - First Posted on 9/20/2006 11:18:00 AM by TomToll


Failure to exercise the care toward others which a reasonable or prudent person would do in the circumstances, or taking action which such a reasonable person would not. Negligence is accidental as distinguished from "intentional torts" (assault or trespass, for example) or from crimes, but a crime can also constitute negligence, such as reckless driving. Negligence can result in all types of accidents causing physical and/or property damage, but can also include business errors and miscalculations, such as a sloppy land survey. In making a claim for damages based on an allegation of another's negligence, the injured party (plaintiff) must prove: a) that the party alleged to be negligent had a duty to the injured party-specifically to the one injured or to the general public, b) that the defendant's action (or failure to act) was negligent-not what a reasonably prudent person would have done, c) that the damages were caused ("proximately caused") by the negligence. An added factor in the formula for determining negligence is whether the damages were "reasonably foreseeable" at the time of the alleged carelessness.

Comment 7 - First Posted on 9/20/2006 11:32:00 AM by 10716

Thank you so much Tom, because I would be arriving to 1st meeting with that being a possible causation of peril which in my "fire claim" inexperience would want to have to been addressed.  I read here at CADO...."cause, coverage, cost".   I would want to work smarter, not harder.

Comment 8 - First Posted on 9/20/2006 11:35:00 AM by TomToll

 If my neighbor had a tree and it was rotten at the base and neither of us realized, then the tree falls on my house. There is no intentional negligence involved, no torte liability involved.

Now, I noticed the tree rot and confronted the neighbor that if it fell, it may hit my house and he disagrees. I contact an arborist and he agrees with my thoughts. I then send him a certified letter to get the tree cut down to prevent damage to my house if it fell, (leaning toward my house) and he disregards the certified letter. That is intentional neglect and becomes a legal torte. His HO carrier would then get involved to make a determination of negligence. Armed with the copy of the letter, I am sure the HO carrier would accept the liability of damages.

 Correct me if I am wrong, please.


Comment 9 - First Posted on 9/20/2006 11:43:00 AM by 10716

Thank you again Tom.  I can now picture with experienced insight just how negligence is applied or addressed in claims or interpretation of policy.  This is greatly appreciated by me because I am not presently available to "ride along" to a fire and be explained to face to face while in the passenger seat what you so graciously just provide.


Comment 10 -  First Posted on 9/20/2006 11:59:00 AM by 10716

 I need to know the cause of the fire right?

 I need to know charges if any from the fire dept. to come out to insureds right?

 I need to address the personal property right?

Categories: CADO Blog, Fire Claims
Tags: Fire
Rate this article:
No rating

Please login or register to post comments.


Popular Post

Quick Tip - Xactimate v25: Adjusting O&P Per Claim

In this quick tip we cover issues related to Overhead & Profit (O&P) that you may encounter in the field.  Some clients may request that you handle O&P in a different way then what your current default settings allow.  In those cases you may only wish to change the settings on a selected file instead of changing your system setup. 

Saturday, July 12, 2008/Author: Roy/Number of views (122548)/Comments (0)/
Categories: CADO BlogSoftware
Tags: Xactimate
Do it right the first time and reduce re-opens

Do it right the first time and reduce re-opens

This article was moved from the old system. It was written by George Mullet in 2000. The primary thing an adjuster needs to do is communicate with the insured. I cannot emphasize that enough. We do not know if there is an error, an oversight or what, until we get out there. The adjuster is always supposed to communicate the proposed settlement with an insured and many people tell us they...
Saturday, March 31, 2007/Author: Roy/Number of views (98528)/Comments (0)/
View From the Slough, Too - The Art and Science of Branch Assist

View From the Slough, Too - The Art and Science of Branch Assist

View From the Slough, Too The Art and Science of Branch Assist By Steve Ebner (   I originally wrote this article back in 2001, and hundred of people read it on CADO, but at some point the link to the article became bad. So, for years I have not even been able to access it. I thought the article was lost for good until I recently discovered it on an old...
Tuesday, August 07, 2007/Author: Medulus/Number of views (84452)/Comments (0)/

Comparative Performance of EPDM As Protection Against Hail Damage

By Ric Vitiello is president of Benchmark Services Inc. "Among the most serious and challenging threats to the performance of any roofing system is hail damage. Failure of a roof membrane due to hailfall can result in flooding and damage to inventory and equipment. Protecting against hail damage is one of the ultimate tests of any roofing ...
Tuesday, March 04, 2008/Author: Roy/Number of views (83949)/Comments (0)/
Categories: CADO Blog

Common Estimating Errors

By John Postava;  First posted in the forum. "They say there have been more mistakes made by computers than Tequila and Hand Guns combined.  That being said, with the help of one of the top trainers at Vale National Training Center we published a white paper on what we feel are some of the top ...
Friday, February 29, 2008/Author: Roy/Number of views (82563)/Comments (0)/
Categories: CADO Blog
Catadjusting and Crisis Intervention

Catadjusting and Crisis Intervention

This is an article I have considered writing for years, one that deals with some of the emotional/psychological elements of working with people who have experienced personal crisis as a result of a catastrophic event, especially with regard to what this means for effective claim settlement.

Thursday, August 16, 2007/Author: Roy/Number of views (82501)/Comments (0)/
They don't just hand you the keys.

They don't just hand you the keys.

This article comes from a forum post that was made by rass3742 on 9/12/2006 One thing I’ve noticed is the incessant struggle between newbies and veterans of our industry, as they scrimmage to identify the paradigm of CAT adjusting.  As a veteran of claims adjusting myself, I have taken the long road here and know that I am better for it. I have just recently become...
Friday, February 16, 2007/Author: Roy/Number of views (82293)/Comments (0)/


State-run insurer of last resort bears much of coastal cost By Mary Williams Walsh © 2008 The New York Times, Reproduced under license from the Copyright Clearance Center Hurricane Ike caused as much as $16 billion in property damage, by some estimates, but the state-led insurance pool that will ...
Wednesday, September 17, 2008/Author: Roy/Number of views (75655)/Comments (0)/
Categories: CADO Blog
Ladder Safety

Ladder Safety

This is a repost of the article. We are moving all articles from the old format to the new format. As hail season approaches we want to remind everybody to think ladder safety each and ever time you grab that ladder. OSHA has reported that the most recent accident statistics suggest that the working men and women in America abuse and misuse ladders in the workplace as a rule rather than an...
Friday, March 30, 2007/Author: Roy/Number of views (72663)/Comments (0)/
Categories: CADO Blog

Flooding the Market with Useless Prospects: CAT Adjusters and Training

An opinion by Phillip Crimaldi  "I’m fairly certain, at least from my own research, that a few things happened somewhere around the post-Katrina era.  First, a handful of hardworking independent adjusters made a bunch of money.  The adjusting companies who had the contracts for those claims made millions, and some of them made successful businesses that continue to...
Thursday, June 12, 2014/Author: CADO Admin/Number of views (40781)/Comments (0)/
Are you ready for the life as a Cat Adjuster or road warrior?

Are you ready for the life as a Cat Adjuster or road warrior?

By Rob Britton @ AmericanWay

The life of a road warrior can be hard, not only on the traveler but also on his or her family. Experienced business travelers explain how they MAINTAIN THE PERSONAL-PROFESSIONAL BALANCE...

Friday, May 24, 2013/Author: Roy/Number of views (28666)/Comments (0)/
Tags: Adjusters
Cat Adjusting as a Profession (Is It For Me?)

Cat Adjusting as a Profession (Is It For Me?)

Article Archive

From the Article Archive  Title: Cat Adjusting as a Profession (Is It For Me?) First Posted: Friday, November 26, 2004 Author: Gary White My son is now ready to go to college away from home and excluding approximately 21 months in an attempt to try something different in my life as a "financial planner", I have been adjusting, supervising or investigating claims for...
Sunday, July 06, 2014/Author: Roy/Number of views (20688)/Comments (0)/
Tags: Adjusters
The “Killer” amongst us.

The “Killer” amongst us.

A article by Dave Hood

 There are many ways to approach the demise of the catastrophe adjuster.    1) The fatal auto accident.    2) The falling off the roof.   3) The stroke   4) The heart attack Many of the above are related to the difficult and lengthily work hours we endure to provide our services to those that require them, as well as to provide for...
Friday, June 08, 2007/Author: CADO Admin/Number of views (17784)/Comments (0)/

Quick Tip - Xactimate 27, Training Book

 If you are currently working with Xactimate 27, then you may wish to get the Training Workbook.

Monday, April 19, 2010/Author: Roy/Number of views (14187)/Comments (0)/
Categories: CADO Blog
Tags: Xactimate