You are exactly right about an overlay. As a contractor, I have overlayed a lot of plastic laminate counter tops with another layer of laminate, with ceramic tile, and 12x12 granite tiles. If using tile, you have to rip the leading edge off with a circular saw first. Although I have not had this happen yet, If I were to adjust a countertop where just the laminate was damaged (you can't overlay if water has gotten into the particle board) I would write it up as a complete tear out and like kind replacement, but if it is an ACV claim and it leaves them with an insufficient amount after depreciation to actually have the work done, they could use this method and have a contractor do an overlay cheaper. One note, however- any time plastic laminate is overlayed, a belt sander with very a coarse belt needs to be used to rough up the top to eliminate the slick surface. |